On November 20, 2026, Derek Hobbs left Lead Gen Jay a one-star review on Trustpilot. He hired us in October 2025 to build a custom cold email system for his company, GradSpecs. This is the postmortem.
What he came to us with
Three days before he signed, Derek filled in our intake form. In his words:
- What his company does: "We create custom software solutions for mid-sized businesses, supporting their growth by guiding them through a digital transformations."
- Who he wanted to reach: "We're targeting mid-sized to enterprise manufacturing companies (100–5,000 employees) that are actively undergoing digital transformation, ERP modernization, or quality system overhauls."
- Asked if he had any relevant case studies: "No, but I have customer references and at least one testimonial"
- Asked about testimonials, awards or rankings: "No"
Custom software, sold by cold email to manufacturers with 100 to 5,000 employees, with no case study on his intake form. That is about as hard as cold email gets.
Six changes of direction
We built each of these six changes.
- October 30, 2025: his team sent back their own version of our first drafts: "while the copy is strong, it doesn't fully reflect the Grad Specs brand... Below is our updated copy".
- May 20, 2026: "Let's drop manufacturing and PE firms from the list and focus on CIO's and M&A."
- June 17: he turned the campaign toward referrals, added a private equity list, and wrote the opening email of each sequence himself: "My contributions are the first emails."
- July 8: "This is looking better! With the PE and M&A campaigns, I would love if you could weave in how we permanently increase EBITDA as a result of our work."
- September 14: "Maybe we should focus on the Fractional CIO's for the remaining leads."
- September 18: he proposed a different offer: "Maybe instead of what is realistic to build in 6 weeks vs 6 months, we just give our analysis of the challenges and possible solutions to start the conversation?"
He asked for the split test in writing. On November 4, 2025 he wrote: "I thought we could split test it against your copy?" We ran his team's copy and ours as separate campaigns.
The case study
In September 2026 we asked again: our September 15 strategy plan listed "One real case study we can reference (industry, size, and outcome, no client name needed)".
On October 8 he wrote: "Ok so it looks like I need to get you some kind of case study. I'll work on getting you that by EOD tomorrow." On October 14: "I have the copy and I'm just getting it polished up." Two client examples were written into the relaunch campaign we created on November 2, 2026.
What we put in
Eight campaigns. Five rounds of rewritten copy in 2026. Two written strategy plans in September 2026 alone.
Staying the course
On September 17, 2026 he wrote: "Let's stay the course until the engagement contractually ends. Just one win pays for the entire engagement."
We did our best here, but we're not magicians. Jonathan Garces, our Director of Client Success, will contact Derek directly.
Jay Feldman



